Yalta ended the British Empire. Yalta 2.0 may end American power - The Telegraph
Churchill, Roosevelt and Stalin at the Yalta conference in 1945 Credit: Ann Ronan Pictures/Print Collector Tom Tugendhat Show biography The Rt Hon Tom Tugendhat is the Conservative MP for Tonbridge.
Hubris and empire are partners. The ambition to reach beyond has driven leaders to ignore the heat and rise towards the sun. Croesus, king of Lydia and the richest man of his age, grew overconfident when the Oracle at Delphi told him that if he made war on Persia he would destroy a great empire. Like so many who have reached the top, he heard what he wanted to hear, crossed the Halys and lost everything. The empire destroyed was his own.
On Thursday, in Shenzhen, Donald Trump will sit down with Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin for what some are calling a new Yalta, after the summit at which Britain, the United States and the Soviet Union decided what the world would look like after the war. There may be more parallels than we would like.
In that cold February of 1945 Churchill, Roosevelt and Stalin met in a Crimean palace. Our prime minister had pressed for the meeting for months, and both he and the US president travelled thousands of miles because the Soviet leader would not leave Soviet soil. The venue was awful, the conditions basic and little worked, but the location was the message. The Red Army stood on the Oder and its commander would not be moved.
In that remote corner of the old Russian Empire it wasn’t the Third Reich that was destroyed; that was being settled on the battlefields to the north. It was Britain’s own imperial ambition that ended there. The warnings were clear.
President Trump arrived in Manila on Tuesday before back-to-back summits with world leaders Credit: loisa Lopez/ Pool/Getty Images Roosevelt would not agree a joint approach beforehand. He didn’t want Stalin to think the democracies were ganging up on him, and to back out just when the US thought it might need the Communists to fight Japan. Worse, the president spent the week treating British imperial interests as an obstacle to the peace. The Americans even proposed placing colonial territories under international trusteeship, until Churchill erupted that he would not have the British Empire put in the dock.
He carried the day on that, but the Britain that had gone to war and demanded a meeting of equals was not the Britain that would take its seat in New York when the United Nations moved to its new headquarters.
Britain had gone to war for Poland, and Poland was taken as a Soviet prize. Within three years India was independent; within a dozen, Suez had shown the world the reality of British power. Yalta may not have ended an empire, but it was the moment the new imperialists took their thrones.
Churchill arrived as leader of a quarter of the globe, having fought from the first days of the war. He left as the junior partner.
The photo said it all: Churchill on the left in a greatcoat, Stalin on the right in his marshal’s uniform, and between them Roosevelt. Stalin may have been the host, but Roosevelt was the power. American money and factories had kept Britain and Russia in the war and were essential to the defeat of Nazism. This was America’s empire now.
What story will Thursday’s photo tell? Unless protocol is torn up, Xi Jinping will sit in the centre, as any good host would. But Mr Xi isn’t the host by accident. Trump is crossing the Pacific for the second time this year, after a deal on everything from rare earths to technology, while Putin can hardly say no, given how dependent he is on Chinese support for his war in Ukraine. The East now provides the money and factories that once came from the West. One guest needs a deal, the other needs a patron, and the host need only pose for the picture.
Will Thursday’s photo tell a story anything like this pop art painting by Russian artist Alexey Sergienko? Credit: Andrei Bok/File Photo Russia and America aren’t alone. European countries are looking for their own moment at the table, and for a prize just as elusive: peace in Ukraine. They too should read their Herodotus, or their Churchill, before they press for that moment of influence. They are risking more than they know.
Putin’s ambitions won’t end at a table or in a treaty. He has made that clear in his writing and his warring for more than two decades, and pressure from the White House could leave Brussels isolated and responsible for outcomes it could never control.
Those of us on the frontiers of empires should not revel in these changes.
Having failed to invest in our own defence, and having constrained our people with taxes, regulations and energy prices, we have left our security in the hands of others. Now we have a choice, and it is the one Churchill set out in the 1930s, not the one he made when he took his seat at Yalta.
It is not the seating plan that matters, nor skill in making deals, but strength, economic and military, that turns a seat at the table from a halter into a place of influence. We need to build on partnerships like the Joint Expeditionary Force and CANZUK to make ourselves strong. Apart, each of us waits to learn its fate from a communiqué.
Herodotus records that Croesus, ruined and in chains, sent to Delphi to complain that the gods had deceived him. The priestess replied that he should have asked which empire was meant. We’ll find out on Thursday what the Oracle means this time.


