You Can See Everything is the year’s most essential film - The Telegraph
Elizabeth Holmes is the disgraced founder of biotechnology startup Theranos, who was convicted of federal fraud charges Credit: A24 Robbie Collin Chief Film Critic Show biography Robbie is the Telegraph’s Chief Film Critic. He has been writing about cinema since 2005 and has been nominated twice for Critic of the Year at the UK Press Awards. He has interviewed filmmakers from Martin Scorsese to Hayao Miyazaki, is a regular contributor to BBC Radio 4’s Front Row, and has served on juries at the Cannes Film Festival and the British Independent Film Awards. His favourite film of all time is Singin’ in the Rain. You can follow Robbie on Letterboxd.
You Can See Everything earns its title admirably promptly, with a full-frontal shot of one of its subjects in the shower after a session in the gym. This jaw-slackening documentary records (at least initially) the last 34 days in the lives of the disgraced biotechnology startup founder Elizabeth Holmes and her fiancé Billy Evans before the former began an 11-year prison sentence for fraud in 2023.
The couple invited filmmakers Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim into their home, explains Evans in the opening scene, in the hope of dispelling the widespread public perception of Holmes in the US as a turtleneck-wearing con artist: “radical transparency” is the solution, he intones. Yet the more we see of these two – Evans’s loins included – the less sense we are be able to make of them.
Their motives (for both making the film and plotting an improbable comeback for Holmes’s now-defunct company, Theranos) swim in and out of focus, while superficially sweet vignettes of the pair canoodling on the sofa and raising their two young children begin to feel, somehow, off.
Fielder – a situationist comedian by trade, with bushy salt-and-pepper hair and a black belt in deadpan – asks probing yet empathetic questions about Theranos’s downfall, the trial, and what the couple hope will come next. But he often can’t work out what the answers he gets signify; his most common response is a wary “okaaaay”.
He later approaches the actress Amanda Seyfried, who played Holmes in the 2022 biographical miniseries The Dropout, to see if she can shed light on Holmes’s character and motivations, which leads to Seyfried becoming bizarrely enmeshed in the film in ways that are too surprising, too clever, and also simply too much fun to spoil.
Amanda Seyfried, who played Holmes in the 2022 biographical miniseries The Dropout, becomes bizarrely enmeshed in the film Credit: BBC/Beth Dubber Meanwhile, Evans keeps interrupting potentially fruitful interviews, embarks on a series of bizarre business ventures of his own (including the creation of an endlessly manipulable AI avatar of Holmes), and tries to strong-arm the directors into giving him a cut of the film’s profits, seemingly – though perhaps not actually – behind his partner’s back.
“I’m always being real,” Holmes tells him in one scene, blue eyes wet and wide, lips parted, head nodding like a bobblehead being driven over cobbles. But “realness”, the film suggests, may itself be entirely unconnected to what we used to call truth, more a newly evolved strain of performance.
Holmes and her fiancé Billy Evans, who tries to strong-arm the directors into giving him a cut of the film’s profits Credit: Getty Images/Philip Pacheco For British audiences, who might not be as familiar with Holmes’s story as their American counterparts, the film is less interesting as a Louis Theroux-like exercise in fly-on-the-wall portraiture than a hilarious and devastating commentary on our post-truth age. Yet there are older, more luxuriantly shadowy forces at work here, too.
Oppenheim and Fielder understand that their setup – an attractive, shady couple, a California beach house, a headline-grabbing crime, an air of swirling confusion – is the basis of film noir. They have built their film like a vintage conspiracy thriller, with its intricate nested revelations, scrutinising close-ups that are somehow simultaneously unflattering and beautiful, and a luscious, velvety score by Ari Balouzian.
Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim build their film like a vintage conspiracy thriller Credit: Getty Images/JC Olivera You Can See Everything is already being described as 2026’s unlikeliest serious Oscar contender, but it is less a dark horse in the coming awards season than a camel in a wig that has somehow bluffed its way into the paddock. It is to our present moment what Francis Ford Coppola’s The Conversation and Alan Pakula’s The Parallax View were to theirs – which is another way of saying it’s the most essential film of the year.

